Unknown title

The BMW X3 combines the driving pleasure of a sporty saloon with the practical space of an SUV, which has made the model popular with families and business drivers for years. Yet owner experiences and technical analyses show that the X3 is known for specific weak spots that can end up costing you a lot in the long run. Examples include timing chain issues and electronic faults in the iDrive system (BMW’s infotainment system). So is this midsize SUV really as good a choice as many car buyers think?

The position of the BMW X3 in the car market

Since 2003, the BMW X3 has been firmly anchored in the midsize SUV segment. The model fills the gap between the compact X1 and the larger X5, allowing BMW to appeal to a wide audience. The current third generation has been around since 2017 and received a facelift in 2021, including updated headlights and a larger infotainment screen.

With its standard xDrive (BMW’s four-wheel drive system) and a choice between diesel and petrol engines, the X3 suits a wide range of usage profiles. The model competes directly with the Audi Q5, Mercedes-Benz GLC and Volvo XC60. Business drivers in particular appreciate the combination of brand image, load space and relatively low benefit-in-kind tax.

How reliable is the BMW X3 really?

The reliability of the BMW X3 varies greatly depending on model year and engine choice. Various consumer organisations and owner panels consistently place BMW in the middle to lower regions of reliability rankings. These scores lag behind brands such as Lexus, Toyota or Mazda. The X3 is no exception.

In particular, models from the years 2011–2016 show relatively many complaints about engine and transmission problems. The newer generation from 2017 scores better, but remains prone to electronic faults and relatively high maintenance costs. Want to know more about common problems with this brand? Check the overview page on car problems with BMW.

Typical BMW characteristics that affect the X3

BMW models generally share certain technical characteristics that also appear in the X3. These features partly determine the reliability and maintenance costs of the model.

First, BMW regularly applies advanced technology that has not yet been fully developed. This sometimes leads to teething problems in new generations. Second, the brand uses relatively many electronic components and sensors for driver assistance systems and comfort features. That increases the likelihood of faults as the car ages.

In addition, BMW demands strict compliance with maintenance intervals, often with more expensive specific parts and lubricants. If maintenance is neglected, problems can occur more quickly than with brands that use simpler designs.

Engines of the BMW X3: where are the weak spots?

The engine problems in the BMW X3 differ depending on the type of powertrain. The most common complaints come from owners with older diesel engines and certain petrol variants.

Timing chain problems with the N20 and N26 petrol engines

The N20 and N26 2.0-litre turbocharged petrol engine, used in the X3 20i from 2011 to 2017, is known for premature wear of the timing chain. This chain can stretch or come loose after just 80,000 to 120,000 kilometres, causing mechanical damage to the engine. Symptoms include a rattling noise when starting or accelerating.

Replacing the chain costs between 1,500 and 2,500 euros, depending on any additional damage. BMW offered a goodwill arrangement for some model years, but this no longer applies to most used cars.

Oil consumption and leaks

Several X3 engines are known for increased oil consumption. This occurs mainly with the straight-six petrol engines (N52, N55) and some diesel variants. Owners often report that they have to top up oil between services.

Possible causes include worn piston rings, damaged rocker cover gaskets or defective PCV valves (crankcase ventilation valves). Regularly check the oil level and have any leaks repaired immediately to prevent more expensive engine damage.

Turbo and intake system issues with diesel engines

The four-cylinder diesel engines, especially the N47 and B47, can suffer from soot build-up in the intake manifold and the EGR valve (exhaust gas recirculation valve). This leads to loss of power, rough idling and increased fuel consumption. With intensive short-distance use, the problem gets worse.

Cleaning the system costs a few hundred euros. Some owners opt for an EGR delete (disabling or removing the EGR system), but this is not permitted in the Netherlands and Belgium due to emissions legislation.

In addition, the turbos on diesel engines can fail due to oil leaks or blocked oil feed lines. A new turbo quickly costs 1,500 to 3,000 euros including labour.

Transmission and xDrive: common faults

The automatic gearboxes in the BMW X3 are generally quite reliable, but even here problems can develop over time.

Jerks and vibrations in the ZF 8-speed automatic

The ZF 8HP automatic transmission (an 8-speed automatic gearbox from manufacturer ZF), standard in most X3 versions, can begin to jerk or hesitate when changing gears at higher mileages. This is usually due to old transmission oil or software that has not been updated.

A transmission oil change and software update improve the gear shifts in many cases. Costs are around 400 to 700 euros. In more serious cases, replacement of internal valves or clutches may be necessary, which is considerably more expensive.

xDrive four-wheel drive and clutches

The xDrive system automatically distributes torque between the front and rear axles. The transfer case and electronic clutches can start to make noise or distribute power unevenly after around 150,000 kilometres.

Symptoms include clicking noises in tight bends, vibrations during acceleration or warning lights on the dashboard. Repairs can run up to 2,000 euros, depending on which component has failed.

Electronics and comfort systems: a source of frustration

BMW is known for advanced electronics, but these systems in particular regularly cause headaches for X3 owners.

iDrive faults and screen failures

The iDrive infotainment system can freeze, respond slowly or fail completely. The first generation iDrive in X3 models from before 2014 is particularly prone to software issues. Sometimes a reset helps, but in some cases hardware replacement is necessary.

Costs for a new iDrive controller or screen can rise to 1,500 euros. When buying a used model, make sure the system works properly, as this repair is expensive.

Sensors and parking assist

The BMW X3 is often equipped with numerous sensors for parking, blind spot monitoring and adaptive cruise control. These sensors can become dirty or fail, leading to annoying warnings on the dashboard.

Cleaning sometimes helps, but replacing defective sensors costs between 200 and 500 euros each. Rear bumper sensors are particularly vulnerable to damage from collisions or black ice.

Lighting and lamp errors

Bi-xenon and LED headlights (headlights with light-emitting diodes) last a long time, but the electronics around them do not always. Error messages about defective lamps regularly appear while the lamps themselves still work. This is due to problems with ballasts or wiring.

Replacing a complete headlight unit with electronics can exceed 1,000 euros. Have the electrical connections and software checked first before buying an expensive light unit.

Suspension, brakes and steering: wear and what to look for

The X3 has a sportily tuned suspension with relatively firm springs. That provides driving pleasure, but also faster wear on certain parts.

Suspension components and bushes

Rubber bushes in the front and rear suspension, such as control arm bushes and anti-roll bar bushes, wear out faster due to the firm set-up and the weight of the car. After 80,000 to 120,000 kilometres, replacement is often needed.

Symptoms include clicking noises over bumps, uneven tyre wear or the car feeling unstable in corners. Replacing a set of bushes costs a few hundred euros in parts and labour.

Brake system and brake discs

The brakes on the X3 perform well, but especially on models with larger wheels and more powerful engines, the brake discs and pads can wear out more quickly. New parts are often needed after 50,000 to 70,000 kilometres.

When looking at used models, watch for rust on the inside of the discs and check whether the brake pads still have sufficient thickness. A complete set of brakes front and rear costs between 600 and 1,200 euros including fitting.

Steering system and power assistance

The electric power steering is generally reliable, but in older models it can falter or produce a knocking sound. This is sometimes due to software problems or defective sensors in the steering column.

In severe cases, the power steering unit may need to be replaced, which can cost more than 1,500 euros. Have warning lights or abnormal behaviour checked immediately.

What to do if you experience problems with your BMW X3?

If you recognise problems early, you often prevent more expensive consequential damage. Watch out for these signs:

• Unusual noises such as rattling, clicking or knocking
• Warning lights on the dashboard that stay on
• Loss of power, jerking or hesitation when accelerating
• Increased fuel or oil consumption
• Strange smells, such as burning odours or exhaust fumes in the cabin

Have the car checked by a BMW specialist or a garage with experience of the brand. They have the right diagnostic equipment to read fault codes and carry out targeted repairs. Avoid ignoring problems, as with BMW small faults can quickly grow into expensive repairs.

Maintenance that prevents problems with the X3

Preventive maintenance is important for a BMW X3 to extend its lifespan and avoid costly repairs. Follow these guidelines:

• Follow the prescribed maintenance intervals strictly, even if the car covers few kilometres
• Always use the oil and filters specified by BMW
• Check the oil level monthly and top up if necessary
• Have the transmission oil changed at 80,000 to 100,000 kilometres, even if this is not listed in the service schedule
• Replace coolant and brake fluid according to schedule
• Clean the sensors and cameras regularly to prevent error messages
• Let the engine warm up before accelerating hard, especially with turbo engines
• Have software updates installed at the dealer to resolve known issues

Keep all maintenance invoices. When selling, a complete service history increases the value and confidence of potential buyers.

Checklist for buying a used BMW X3

Are you considering buying a used X3? Then pay attention to these points to avoid disappointment:

• Check whether the service book is complete and the prescribed services have been carried out
• Ask whether the timing chain has been replaced on N20/N26 engines over 80,000 kilometres
• Test all electronics thoroughly: iDrive, sensors, lighting, seat heating and other functions
• Check for visible oil leaks under the engine
• Watch for warning lights on the dashboard and have any fault codes read
• Take a test drive with a cold engine to detect timing chain noises
• Test the transmission by accelerating and decelerating smoothly; watch for jerks or hesitation
• Check the condition of the suspension bushes and the state of the brake discs and tyres
• Ask about the history of the xDrive system if the model has four-wheel drive
• Consider an inspection report from an independent specialist

Models from 2018 onwards with the updated B-series engines generally score better on reliability than older generations. Be especially cautious with examples from before 2014.

Does the driving pleasure outweigh the maintenance costs?

The BMW X3 undeniably offers a dynamic driving experience that many competitors do not match. The chassis responds sharply, the engines deliver strong performance and the finish exudes premium quality. For those who enjoy engaging handling and brand image, the X3 offers a lot of car for the money.

At the same time, you have to be realistic about the costs. Maintenance and repairs are more expensive than with popular Japanese or Korean brands. Problems with the timing chain, electronics or xDrive coupling can quickly run into the thousands of euros. So set aside a substantial annual budget for maintenance and unexpected repairs.

For anyone who maintains the BMW X3 according to schedule, looks critically when buying and is prepared to invest in quality maintenance, the model remains an attractive choice. It combines practical space with sportiness in a way that few other SUVs can match. However, those mainly looking for carefree and cheap motoring would be better off considering more proven reliable alternatives such as the Lexus RX or Toyota RAV4.

Contents