Relay faults make Tonale diagnosis difficult

Relay faults make Tonale diagnosis difficult

Relay faults in the Tonale can sometimes cause problems that seem much bigger than a single small electrical component: from starting issues and lights cutting out to warnings from the hybrid system. Yet a relay is by no means always the cause, because a weak 12V battery, a poor earth, wiring harness damage or software can produce exactly the same symptoms. Anyone who measures carefully and checks recall actions can avoid unnecessary parts replacement. Read on before you blame a relay as the culprit.

Recognising an electrical relay fault in the Tonale

A relay is an electrically operated switch. With a small control current, it switches a larger current for, for example, lighting, a cooling fan or a fuel pump. In the Alfa Romeo Tonale, partly faulty relays can therefore cause awkward, inconsistent symptoms. The relay may still click, but the contacts do not pass on enough voltage because of wear or burning.

That makes the fault deceptive. A system may work again temporarily after restarting, only to fail again later. With Alfa Romeo Tonale problems it is therefore sensible not only to look at fault codes, but also at the supply voltage under load. A fault code often indicates that a component received insufficient power, not automatically why that happened.

A relay fault is especially likely when one specific function fails while the rest of the car works normally. If the lights, power steering, brake assistance and multiple warnings fail at the same time, a shared power supply, earth, wiring harness or control module is more likely.

What are common relay problems?

Broadly speaking, a relay consists of a coil and switching contacts. The coil receives a signal from a control module. The contacts then connect the power supply to a consumer. An audible click therefore only proves that the coil is probably moving. It does not prove that the relay is also passing current properly.

These are the most logical technical causes of electrical relay faults in the Tonale:

  • Burnt contacts that create excessive resistance.
  • An open-circuit relay coil, causing the relay no longer to switch.
  • Corrosion in the relay base or a connector plug.
  • A poor earth connection between the battery, bodywork and consumer.
  • A fuse holder or cable that makes insufficient contact because of heat.
  • A control issue from the Body Control Module, the control module that controls electrical body functions among other things, or another control module.

That last cause in particular is often underestimated. The Tonale uses several control modules that work together via the data network. When a module gives no command because of low voltage, software logic or a communication fault, a perfectly good relay can remain switched off. Replacing it then solves nothing.

A voltage dip often looks like a relay fault

The 12V battery is also important for the Tonale Plug-in Hybrid. The car uses that battery to start the control modules, contactors and various electrical systems. A battery can show a reasonable voltage when stationary, yet still sag significantly during starting or when the hybrid system is activated.

That can lead to a cluster of fault messages, a refusal to start, or systems becoming available again after a restart. According to general diagnostic guidelines, it is therefore necessary to carry out a measurement under load. Do not only measure open-circuit voltage, but also the voltage during starting and the voltage drop across positive cables and earth points.

Specific Tonale faults that resemble relay issues

Early Alfa Romeo Tonale examples deserve attention to the wiring harness under the floor. For cars produced according to recall information between 15 September 2022 and 13 February 2023, a possible fault in the underfloor wiring has been reported. This can cause, among other things, the lights, hazard warning lights, electric power steering and brake assistance to fail.

This pattern does not fit a single relay and points to a shared problem in the power supply or wiring. According to official recall information, you should have the vehicle identification number checked if you experience these symptoms. Based on the year of manufacture alone, it is not possible to determine whether a specific Tonale is covered by a campaign.

Plug-in Hybrid connections need extra attention

For certain Tonale Plug-in Hybrid models from the 2023 and 2024 model years, campaigns have been reported relating to the positive 12V cable and high-voltage connectors. A connection that is not secured sufficiently can build up resistance and become hot. The consequences range from fault messages and a hybrid system that is unavailable to visible discolouration or a smell of burning.

A drive system that is temporarily unavailable can be mistaken for a relay problem. Official information from Stellantis states that the connections must be checked and, where necessary, secured correctly. Never work on orange high-voltage cables, battery connectors or parts of the hybrid system yourself.

Stop and have the car checked if you notice any of these signs:

  • A smell of burning, melting or visible heat discolouration at a connection.
  • A warning for the hybrid or high-voltage system.
  • Sudden loss of power steering or brake assistance.
  • Multiple electrical functions stopping at the same time.
  • A car that switches off while driving or will no longer engage drive.

Carrying out a diagnosis of a defective Alfa Romeo relay

A proper diagnosis of a defective relay in an Alfa Romeo starts with measuring, not replacing. A relay is relatively cheap, but swapping parts at random can hide the real cause. Especially when the fault is intermittent, a workshop gains more from measured values and stored fault data than from a message that has disappeared.

The correct order for investigation is as follows:

  1. Check the condition of the 12V battery and the battery terminals.
  2. Measure voltage and voltage drop during starting or when the relevant function is switched on.
  3. Check fuses not only visually, but also for voltage on both sides.
  4. At the relay, measure the supply, earth, coil trigger and output to the consumer.
  5. Read all control modules and save the fault codes with freeze-frame data.
  6. Inspect connectors, wiring looms and earth points for moisture, corrosion, loose pins and heat.
  7. Have the VIN checked for open recalls and software campaigns.

Freeze-frame data are the values the car stores at the moment a fault occurs. Think of battery voltage, temperature, speed and operating status. In a fault that disappears after a restart, this information can distinguish between a defective relay and a temporary voltage dip.

Do not test a relay by click sound alone

A multimeter is useful, but a load test is better. If you measure 12 volts after a relay with no load, the relay can still fail as soon as a consumer demands current. The contact resistance then shows up as a voltage loss. A cooling fan, pump or lamp receives too little voltage and does not work, or only works intermittently.

Also have the relay base inspected. Loose contacts in the base can produce the same symptoms as faulty contacts in the relay itself. If there are signs of moisture or green corrosion, the connector must be repaired before you look further.

‘ The result looks like a faulty stop relay or fuel pump relay, but the interruption is then being deliberately commanded. ’

Starting problems are not always a starter relay

A Tonale that fires briefly and then stalls may have an immobiliser issue. That security system can block ignition, injection or fuel delivery when the key is not properly recognised. The result looks like a faulty stop relay or fuel pump relay, but the interruption is then being deliberately commanded.

First carry out simple checks. Try the spare key and look for a key or immobiliser symbol in the instrument panel. Also keep the key away from other RFID cards or electronic keys. If both keys still cause problems, have the antenna ring, immobiliser module and communication with the engine computer checked.

Alfa Romeo Tonale

Practical approach when buying a used Tonale

When buying a used Tonale, a test drive is not enough on its own. Electrical faults sometimes only appear on a cold start, after a long period standing still or while charging. Ask for a diagnostic readout and check whether the service documentation mentions software campaigns or recall work.

During an inspection, pay particular attention to fault messages after starting, erratic behaviour from electrical systems and signs of previous cable repairs. On a Plug-in Hybrid, also check whether charging completes without interruption. A professional pre-purchase inspection is advisable when there are stored voltage, communication or hybrid faults.

On the Carnews website you can find much more about faults, recalls, maintenance and known points of attention for Alfa Romeo and other brands. Discover more related topics on Carnews before making a diagnosis or purchase decision.

Frequently asked questions

The relay faults can technically be caused by burnt or stuck contacts, an open-circuit relay coil, corrosion in the relay base or poor power and earth connections. In the Tonale, relay faults often appear to stem from a weak 12V battery, faulty plugs or wiring looms, including the underfloor wiring and insufficiently secured 12V or high-voltage connections. Software or control module problems and the immobiliser can also block relay control, making a relay appear faulty when it is not.

Typical early signs are intermittent failure of electrical functions, a clicking sound without the connected component working, starting problems and faults that temporarily disappear after a restart. Multiple simultaneous warnings or the sudden loss of lights, power steering or brake assistance can also occur. A smell of burning or melting, heat discolouration and warm connectors point to overheating and require immediate inspection. However, these symptoms can also be caused by a weak battery, poor wiring, connectors or software problems.

Switch off the ignition, disconnect the negative terminal of the 12V battery according to the manual and find the relay using the fuse box diagram. Check the relay and base for corrosion, loose contacts or heat damage and use a multimeter to test the coil and switched contacts; hearing only a click is not enough. If necessary, test it by temporarily swapping the relay with a proven good, identical relay and replace it only with the same type and specifications. Never work on orange high-voltage cables or components in a hybrid and call in a specialist if you are in any doubt.

The electrical problems reduce the reliability of both powertrains because voltage, wiring harness and software faults can cause starting problems, warnings and temporary system failures. In the Mild Hybrid, the 12V/48V supply, connectors and software are particularly vulnerable. In the PHEV, the impact is potentially more serious because loose 12V and high-voltage connections can cause failure, overheating and even a fire risk. Early examples from 2022 and 2023 in particular can only be assessed as reliable once all recalls and software updates have been carried out.

No general recall or permanent technical modification is known for the ‘relay problem’ itself. Alfa Romeo has, however, issued VIN-specific recalls and campaigns for related wiring harness, connector and software problems on certain Tonales. Therefore, have a dealer check which measures apply based on the VIN.